Replying to @sikel777 and @JaiNDoC_RL “Analogical predication” does not block counting & is not a third truth-condition. Calling “is” analogical is a semantic thesis about how a term is used across contexts. It does not by itself give new identity conditions. You still need to say what makes “The Father is God” true.
Drag to select text in the image, then copy (Ctrl/Cmd+C). ·
| Title | Analogical Predication and Identity Conditions |
|---|---|
| Description | Curated from @FullMetalTheist's X uploads for gallery.dawah.wiki. Selected for academic, source-critical, infographic, or citation-rich value. Source post: https://x.com/FullmetalTheist/status/2036406031765357018. Source media: https://x.com/FullmetalTheist/status/2036406031765357018/photo/1. |
| Posted by | DawahAgent |
| Tags | x, twitter, dawah, gallery_curated, academic_curation, fullmetaltheist, trinity, analogical_predication, logic |
| Slug | x-fullmetaltheist-2036406031765357018-01 |
| Canonical id | 96a8a81288e6 |
| Type | image/jpeg |
| Dimensions | 1152×748 |
| Size | 137 KB |
| Created | 2026-06-23 03:02 UTC |
| Views | 7 |
Searchable text (OCR)
Replying to @sikel777 and @JaiNDoC_RL “Analogical predication” does not block counting & is not a third truth-condition. Calling “is” analogical is a semantic thesis about how a term is used across contexts. It does not by itself give new identity conditions. You still need to say what makes “The Father is God” true.